// the theo-economy of dating: why hot and holy isn’t enough //
“i have a serious question for you,” she said.
the look in her eyes betrayed raw nerves, weariness, and a hint of something that i tried to convince myself i was only mistaking for masked anger.
“i need your advice. i went to coffee with a girlfriend this week, and she was telling me all about this wonderful guy she’s talking to, and she was so excited about it.
the next day i went to coffee with another girlfriend, and we had almost the exact same conversation. and then i realized.
they were both talking about the same guy.”
turns out i wasn’t mistaken at all. this friend of mine was downright furious. here’s the kicker though. she wasn’t just mad at some creep, the guy in question is a well respected member of our community and is even in some leadership roles at a local church.
and the thing that gets me is that this isn’t the first time i’ve had someone come to me with heartbreak, headache, or frustration over this guy and guys like him. not even close. there seems to be a culture of “open-mindedness” that borders on irreverence when it comes to dating within the church, and i think it needs to be addressed.
so i’ve decided to put my pen to paper, or my fingers to keyboard about this issue.
the culture:
a couple months ago i was able to make it to a college age group one night and as it would happen, the topic was dating.
now, the speaker that night was a man i have a lot of respect for, and have been very blessed by his teachings in the past, i want to affirm that right now. but that night
i heard a teaching that, without clarification, could be dangerous. we were told that in the church, we have the tendency to take dating too seriously. he encouraged guys to take the leap and ask girls out. and he encouraged girls that saying “yes” to a date didn’t mean that you were going to get married, it just meant that you were going on a date.
now, there are guys i know, great guys, that are so afraid of rejection they can’t bring themselves to ask out a girl that they know and admire and respect and really want to pursue a relationship with. in that case, i one-hundred percent agree. ask her out.
likewise, there are girls i know, great girls, that have been so pushed away from dating by the hoards of recreational daters and just plain no-good-guys around, that when a godly, respectably guy comes along that knows her, respects her, and wants to pursue her, she freaks out.
or
there are other girls i know, great girls, that have been so inundated with the prince charming // hollywood hunk image in our society that when a godly, respectable guy comes along that knows her, respects her, and wants to pursue her, but he doesn’t have brad pitt’s side abs or zack effron’s hair or doesn’t look anything like david beckham, she shuts him down faster than ____. in these cases, i agree. if this guy is a good guy that knows and respects, and wants to pursue you, and you find him attractive, it’s not going to kill you to say yes to a date.
but here’s the problem with that.
for every guy that needs to hear “go for it,” there are a handful of guys that need to hear “you better think twice.”
and for every girl that needs to hear “give him a chance,” there are a handful of girls that need to hear “make sure you know what you’re saying yes to.”
while it may sound nice to say that dating should be just two people getting to know each other, not so much about emotional attachment and planning ahead, we don’t live in that ideal of a world.
we live in a world with emotions and anticipations and hopes.
when you ask a girl on a date you are communicating that you are interested in her. and after a few dates, if you tell her “hey i respect you a lot and think you’re great, but i just don’t see it working out between us. you understand right?” ….you might be thinking that that is what dating is, how dating should work…. but what you are communicating to her is that you were interested in her until you got to know her, and then you got to know her and are no longer interested.
it doesn’t take a genius to see the effect that is most likely going to come from that.
and so i’ve had several friends that are amazing girls bring this to my attention. they feel like they’ve been weighed and found wanting. and now they’re examining themselves to see why they don’t measure up, what is wrong with themselves.
multiply that by a church body full of single, godly, beautiful girls, and factor in a culture of guys that think the way dating works is: hey she’s hot, she’s holy, i’m going to ask her to coffee.
and you can see the problem.
we are creating a culture of disappointments // frustrations at the very least, and heartbreak // self doubt on the more serious end. and i can’t help but think that this approach to dating and relationships is not in line with God’s heart for shalom, for wholeness, for unity. individually as well as corporately.
the community:
it’s not my goal here to point the finger, to say shame on you, guys. neither is it my goal to paint the image of girls as these helpless victims. i know that we live in a fallen world, and i will be the first to admit that much of the conviction in this essay is from personal experiences and mistakes.
and i know that girls are often just as responsible for baring their hearts too early, too often, too much.
and i’m not communicating that dating is evil.
trust me, i’ve wrestled with these issues. a lot.
trying to fit biblical principles into the context of our modern times and approach to relationships. let’s face it, arranged marriages are out. thirty to forty year old men marrying fourteen year old girls is out.
our culture is just different from ones in biblical times. but our God is the same. and his heart for his people is the same. he desires grace and peace. shalom. wholeness. relationships centered around him and his glory. unity. building one another up, pushing each other along on our walks, our journeys toward God. coming alongside each other on our mission to partner in the kingdom, both coming and here already.
in that light, it is imperative that we examine our interactions with one another.
especially when it comes to this issue of dating.
are we contributing to shalom?
or are we contributing to frustration, heart break, self doubt.
are we building each other up?
or are we tearing each other down?
are we pushing each other towards God?
or are we distracting and side-tracking each other?
are we seeking after God’s heart for pursuing relationships?
or are we seeking after a “hot, holy” girl // guy?
God created human beings for community. he himself exists in community. with the Son and the Holy Spirit. we are created to need community, to crave it, to thrive in it.
so why do we give in to the hollywood idea of “you and me against the world?”
how do godly guys i know consistently ask girls out on dates, not knowing these girls very well, not knowing their families, not being friends with them, not being in community with them?
and then once they get to know these girls a little bit, they move on, having not found what they were looking for. leaving behind them a trail of confusion, disappointment, and doubt. and on to the next.
i’m sorry guys, hot and holy is not enough.
stop asking girls out. stop texting them. stop telling them they look beautiful. instead, be their friend. be in their community.
they don’t have a community? let them be a part of yours. not with selfish, ulterior motives, but because that is what God desires: unity. wholeness. love for one another. we should be embracing each other and showing love to each other whether or not we find a person attractive, whether we are interested them as dating potential or not. obviously, i’m talking about doing this in an appropriate way.
you don’t have a community? well my friend, you need to pray about how God desires to change your relational mindset. it’s his desire for us to be in community. communities take work. they take patience. but God created us for them. both community with him, and with one another.
before i get too tangental here, lets bring it back down to earth.
guys. girls are your sisters before they are anything else. treat them that way. don’t communicate to them that you like them or are interested in them before you know them. before you know you want to pursue them. can’t do that? then back away. because the last thing our community needs is impatient, selfish men that lack self control. what it needs is men who are willing to die to themselves in order to create shalom, to let their sisters know that they are loved, cherished, valued, worthy of our respect and admiration. regardless of if we want to date them or just be their friend. men who are willing to set an example for other men in purity, in self control, in godliness.
men who are working for shalom.
God showed us an example of what living in community should look like. Jesus left the presence of his father to be with us. the Father sacrificed his son to give us a way to himself. the Spirit is here on earth in our hearts putting up with our fallenness, bearing with us in patience.
sacrifice. humility. putting others before yourself. that is what community is about.
and that is God’s desire for us.
so.
how can we contribute to a better community?
how can we be conduits of grace and peace?
how can we build each other up?
how can we work for shalom in our personal lives, in the lives of those around us, in our communities, and in our city?
i know that we have a long way to go on these issues, but i also know that while grace and peace are something that we strive for, they are also something that have been given to us already.
let us be known as a people of grace. a people of peace. a people of shalom.
let the world look at us in wonder of how much respect we have for each other, in how we as men treat our sisters, in how our sisters respond and react to their brothers.
let us be a people that seek first his kingdom.
grace and peace,
ip
